MC starting on d-day was a great help to us. That was because our MC (who was my W's IC, which is how we got time with her on d-day) did NOT indicate in any way that our M or I caused my W's A. Our MC sessions were all about the A all the time until I was done talking about it. Then the sessions were only about the A when I brought it up.
Most of the sessions were about how my W fucked up and what she needed to do to keep doing the right things in the future.
So if your MC asks your W why she cheated and knocks down her reasons, MC can help. If your MC tells your W she's responsible for her choices, MC can help.
*****
The more I think about it, the less I want to rely on WS for healing. She wants to repair things, so that's nice but the more I process this, the more I see a need for self sufficiency. Why set my hopes on such a shaky foundation?
Good insight. Your W simply can't heal you. The only help she can give you is emotional support. You are responsible for healing yourself.
You do that by resolving your feelings - anger, grief, fear, shame, etc. - and letting them go. A good IC can help you do that.
It's a lot easier to say than to do. Trauma is awful in many ways, especially in the way that today's trauma can bring back memories of every other trauma you've experienced. No matter how charmed your life might have been up to now, your brain probably has memories of events it (your brain) decided was traumatic.
You'll probably find one feeling more comfortable than others. You'll have to work through that feeling in order to get to the others. Then you'll have to get through the other feelings.
And none of this is linear - you'll think you're going in circles, and you may be.
But resolving the feelings is eminently doable, and each feeling you resolve frees your energy to resolve others. Each feeling you resolve also clears your mind so you can think straighter and perceive reality with more accuracy.
*****
I understand you don't know much that's useful right now. Being betrayed - any trauma - is disorienting, and the bigger the trauma, the more the disorientation.
My reco is to let your emotions flow and to ride the waves. Aim to figure out what you want. It's entirely possible that you don't want to spend the rest of your life with your W. That probably makes D your better choice.
If you're uncertain, or if you want R, my reco is to think about how you will know if R is working or not. What indicators will tell you how R is proceeding?
Those indicators can be turned into your requirements for R. Share them with your W. If she signs on or negotiates a different requirement that looks good to you, R can start. If she won't sign on, R probably won't work.
The thing is: the requirements need to be observable and measurable. If your W steps up, great. If she fails but corrects her course when she monitors her behavior against the requirements, great. Both are positive for R. If she doesn't step up and/or correct course, great - that's positive for D.
If you keep wanting R, great. If you decide down the line you want D, even if your W is exceeding requirements, great.
Common requirements are: No Contact, total honesty/no more lies about anything, IC for WS with a goal of changing from cheater to good partner, you have total access to all her media, MC if one of you wants it.
Just to make it explicit: I hope you go for the optimal resolution for you - but you have to find your own path from this devastation to a good life. I can't know if that's D or R at this point; maybe you can't, either. But you can hold your head high either way, if you make mindful choices.
*****
It looks like you have faith in yourself. That's a great start. When you fall into self-doubt, remind yourself you can survive and thrive whether you D or R. When you feel weak, remind yourself that healing is DIFFICULT, and focusing on healing takes strength whether you feel strong or not..
And BE PATIENT. Recovery is a marathon , not a sprint. Think 2-5 years to recover. You may heal sooner; healing may take longer. If you choose R, you may R in 2-5 years or sooner or later or not at all.
But 2-5 years is a good rule of thumb, as long as you remember it's just a rule of thumb.
But never forget:
1) You heal you. Your WS may help (or hinder) your healing, but the responsibility is yours, and only you can do the necessary work.
2) Your WS heals themself. You may help (or hinder) their healing, but the responsibility is theirs, and only they can do the necessary work.
3) If you both want to rebuild your M, you can do it. You can even heal your M while you're heaing yourselves.
[This message edited by SI Staff at 6:21 PM, Friday, October 3rd]